Congress Jewelers
2075 Periwinkle Way #35, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-4177
Congress Jewelers is run by husband and wife team, Scot and Melissa. They are third-generation jewelers and they pride themselves on creating exquisite pieces for their customers. If it is an island keepsake you are looking for check out their trademark “SeaLife By Congress”. This collection is inspired by Sanibel and Captiva and aims to express the island’s great beauty. The whole collection is designed and hand-crafted on the island. The island theme is clear and the pieces are a gorgeous reminder of this unique place.
The Cedar Chest Fine Jewelry
1993 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel Island, FL 33957
239-472-2876
The Cedar Chest opened in 1975 and was the first place to have a Sanibel Nature jewelry collection. Founder Pat Zambuto designed the collection. She took inspiration from her love of nature and Sanibel’s unspoiled beauty. The collection is vast and has Sanibel-themed bracelets, rings, pendants, and earrings. The pieces are crafted with gold, silver diamonds, and precious stones. The Cedar Chest also carries a variety of other talented designers.
520 Tarpon Bay Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-2888
Voted the “coolest jewelry store on the island” Lily & Co. specializes in couture Sanibel-themed jewelry. Lily’s is housed in one of Sanibel’s most historic buildings which was built in 1915. The store itself is unique with original art on display which can be purchased. They have a collection of unique designers and they can also come up with custom designs for you or your loved one.
Shiny Objects
1999 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-1660
Shiny Objects has the largest selection of sterling silver and handmade glass jewelry on the islands. They feature fun, tropical designs in cubic zirconia, opal, blue topaz. abalone, mother of pearl, and larimar. The pieces are beautiful and affordable and really do shine!
Suncatchers’ Dream
Olde Sanibel Shops
630 Tarpon Bay Rd # 2, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-7860
Suncatchers’ Dream of Sanibel is an incredibly, unique “must-see” gift store. It has breathtaking merchandise from local and national artists. There is something for everyone and something for every occasion. Suncatchers’ Dream of Sanibel is an exclusive carrier of Dune Jewelry and, in fact, more Dune Jewelry is purchased at Suncatchers’ than at any other place in the world! This delicate and captivating line is all handmade utilizing sand and earth elements from the customer’s favorite place which could be a beach, trail, garden, mountain top, and more.
Pandora’s Box & Pandora’s Box Too
Tahitian Gardens Shopping Plaza
1975 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-6263
Both located in the Tahitian Gardens Shopping Plaza, Pandora’s Box and Pandora’s Box Too have a great selection of unique jewelry. Many of the pieces are made locally and there is a broad price range to suit everyone’s budget. Both stores also carry extensive collections of cool greeting cards and homemade household goods.
Tuttles Seahorse Shell Shop
362 Periwinkle Way #3, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-266-2899
One of the oldest businesses on the island, Tuttles sells some very unique, island-centric jewelry. They have a large variety of bracelets, earrings, necklaces, rings, and charms to choose from. They carry a unique line of Sanibel-specific charms in gold and sterling silver. The charms feature established Sanibel landmarks such as the Lighthouse, palm trees and dolphins.
Traders Of Sanibel
1551 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-7242
Traders Of Sanibel is a highly recommended restaurant but it also has a very popular gift shop attached to it. The gift shop has remarkable items from across the globe and the jewelry is certainly no exception. There are plenty of unique items to choose from so it is worth a visit if you are looking for something special.
