Experience the best shops on Sanibel Island & Captiva Island! There are many stores around providing unique, island-centric items. If you’re looking for clothing, home décor, fabulous gifts, or all the above, there is something for everyone!

Most of the stores, located in pretty, outdoor plazas, are small charming boutiques.

For the hobbyist, there are several specialist stores. Fishing, art & crafts, books, and antiques are all on offer. The various plazas also have great food. There are cafes, restaurants, coffee, and dessert establishments to provide rest and rejuvenation.

Tahitian Gardens Speciality Shoppes Sanibel Island

Best Shops on Sanibel Island

Seahorse Shops

362 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

Sea Horse Shopping Center Sanibel Island

This quaint little shopping center is home to Tuttle’s Seahorse Shell Shop, Lighthouse Cafe, and EmOceans Coastal Wear.

Tuttles Seahorse Shell Shop is one of the oldest businesses on the island providing desirable island souvenirs! This Sanibel Island shop is perfect for take-home pristine shells and unique local artifacts. The owner is always friendly, loves to chat, and is very knowledgeable about the island!
EmOceans Coastal Wear is more than just luxury beach and swimwear! This fashionable gem is also home to every beach essential, the perfect keepsake, and even an ice cream and coffee shop.
Located in Seahorse shops is also Lighthouse Cafe, this award-winning cafe is the perfect spot for a hearty island breakfast!

Heart Of The Island Shops

1620 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

This is one of our personal favorite places to stop in and shop! With such amazing unique boutiques and crafty finds Heart Of The Island Shops is a must visit!

Here you’ll find B Unique Boutique, J.McLaughlin, Sanibel Home Furnishings, and Three Crafty Ladies.

B Unique Boutique is one of many Sanibel Island shops where customer service goes above and beyond. Showcasing a diverse selection of clothing and accessories with tasteful tropical designs and one-of-a-kind pieces, this is an essential for any shopaholic! Great prices, something for everyone, an overall kind and cleanly store!
J. McClaughlin is one of the few chains you’ll find among the Sanibel Island shops! This women’s and men’s clothing store has the perfect pieces for sanibel island summer wear. Quality and classic clothing for all!
Sanibel Home Furnishings has an ever changing show room full of the perfect island home decor! Colorful and stylish furniture, pillows, home decor, and all the accessories. With everything inspired by Sanibel and Captiva this is the best place to bring some of the islands into your home.
Three Crafty Ladies is literally a crafters dream come true! Their selection of fabrics and crafting supplies is truly one of a kind. The staff are wonderful and will help any of your crafting project dreams come to reality. The nautical and tropical theme is just so Sanibel, the prices are perfectly reasonable, and the staff is very knowledgeable!

Jerry’s Shopping Complex

1700 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel FL 33957

This shopping complex is definitely your one-stop shop, with everything you could need just off of Perwinkle Way!

For starters, we have Jerry’s Supermarket and Restaurant, one of Sanibel’s few full-service grocery stores combined with a popular cafe! If you’re staying on the Island Jerry’s has everything you’ll need to grocery shop, check out the cafe for a quick bite!
Footloose & H2O Outfitters have a full selection of apparel, accessories, swimwear, and sunglasses! Footloose also has a full selection of footwear and shoes available making this Sanibel islands go-to shoe shop.
Sanibel Spirits will take care of all your Beer, Wine, & Liquor needs. This Sanibel Island shop is home to a wonderful staff with a great selection of island liquors!
Sanybel’s Finest is a local art gallery full of unique island pieces and artworks! The store owners are just wonderful and will help you find any artwork you may be looking for. There is also a selection of jewelry, crystals, fossils, and trinkets available at this Sanibel Island shop!
Sanibel Surf Shop has everything you’ll need to enjoy the Sanibel waters! From bathing suits to boogie boards this Sanibel Island shop is equipped for an Island adventure. Their gear selection consists of towels, chairs, and umbrellas, and you may even find that perfect souvenir here!
Love Boat Ice Cream is a Fort Myers, Florida favorite, known among all the locals as the best ice cream in town! Soon enough Love Boat made its way over the bridge and a store was opened on the Island. There is a large selection of flavors, shakes, sizes, and more! A must-visit after any long hot day on the beach.
There’s even something for the kids! Nanny’s of Sanibel is an Island shopping staple since 1982. Carrying clothes and swimwear for all ages from newborn to 14 years old, Nanny’s has the perfect beach outfit for the little ones in the family.
Relax and unwind at Spatini Teabar! This full-service salon also doubles as a boba tea bar. Enjoy a massage from one of Spatini’s amazing, professional, and personable staff!

Tahitian Gardens

1975-2019 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

Tahitian Gardens is full of Sanibel Island shopping, from gifts to gear and even a bite to eat look no further than Tahitian Gardens.

Adventures in Paradise is located within the gardens and has a great selection of tours/boat charters for you to enjoy a day on the water! There is also a nice selection of outdoor apparel to purchase for your trip!
Cheeburger Cheeburger is a local favorite! This burger spot is reminiscent of a classic diner with an island twist. Burgers, fries, shakes, and more grab a quick bite after your beach day!
Cedar Chest Fine Jewelry has the perfect piece of Sanibel to take home for any jewelry lover! With an extensive selection of ocean and sealife-themed fine jewels to choose from this Sanibel Island shop is great for gifts or your own personal memento.
Pandora’s Box is home to unique home decor, art pieces, and jewelry! Close by is Pandora’s Box Too known for gifts, stationary, and cards! Both shops are perfect for one-of-a-kind Sanibel keepsakes and trinkets!
Paper Fig Kitchen a local restaurant and caterer is the place to be for a quick breakfast or delicious grab n’ go sandwich!
Sanibel Cafe is an absolute classic Island staple for a fantastic breakfast to get your day started!
Sanibel Resort Wear is a lovely boutique for upmarket Women’s wear designed with the perfect Island style. Beach apparel, unique dresses, and fashionable accessories are all living here at Sanibel Resort Wear!
Sanibel Sole is home to all the best Island footwear! Carrying other small accessories such as sunglasses and beachwear. Hit the beach in style with some Sanibel Soles at your feet!
Shiny Objects name truly speaks for itself! This homey jewelry shop is home to the island’s largest collection of sterling silver and handmade glass jewelry! The staff is amazing and will help make sure you find exactly what you need whether it be an addition to your personal jewelry box or the perfect gift!
Synergy Sportswear has outdoor apparel for the whole family carrying great pieces for men, women, and children! Our favorite thing about Synergy is that they carry Life Is Good, which is always true if you’re on Sanibel Island!
Wilford & Lee is a great place for gifts! With a nice selection of Island themed home accents and treasures you’ll find the perfect home trinket to remember your trip! There are plenty of classic souvenirs such as keychains, stuffed sea life animals for kids, and shells.
One last stop for the kiddos is A Little Adventure, another clothing store in the plaza with children’s beach apparel, and more!

Periwinkle Place

2075 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

Periwinkle Place is perfect if you’re truly trying to go shopping at the best Sanibel island shops! Here you will find a vide variety of fashionable and island style clothing, jewelry, and accessories!

Beach Daisy is a Women’s clothing store focused on creating effortless lifestyle clothing and accessories! The perfect relaxed vibe for a Sanibel ready wardrobe. Carrying a variety of popular clothing lines, there is something for you at the Beach Daisy!
Butterfly Beach has ton’s of trendy finds for all! Fashionable boho and island inspired apparel for women, men, young adults, and children. Definitely worth stopping in and browsing around!
The Original Chico’s is one of few chain shops found on Sanibel Island, however the style is exactly why! This laidback Women’s wear brand is perfect for a vacation dress, new tee, or a nice accessory.
Classic Collections has a very attentive and personable staff looking to help you add to your Sanibel shopping collections. From unique jewelry pieces tp the perfect gift to bring home this little gem is full of homey trinkets and treasures!
Everything But Water quite literally has exactly that! With a huge collection of high-end swim wear for men and women, alongside all the necessary beach apparel and accessories this is the perfect place to find a new beach piece.
Her Sports Closet is a Lily Pulitzer lovers dream! The brand Lily is loved by any Island and this Sanibel shop is home to the most extensive collection. Additionally carrying plenty of apparel for Women beyond Lily Pulitzer as well!
Island Pursuit has classic sportswear for both men and women. This store is best suited for boating fans and those with an active life style. High quality collection of active wear for all!
Sanibellla is the perfect place to relax and unwind on your vacation! Carrying a large supply of all natural products and offering wonderful Spa services, Sanibella is a hidden sanctuary!
The Shady Rooster has one of the best specialty sunglasses collections on the Island! This is the best place to find that perfect pair of stylish sun-blocking shades for men and women alike.
Pinocchio’s has the sweet treat you’re looking for! This original Italian ice cream shop has a wide selection of flavors, perfectly fit to please your sweet tooth and cool you down after a sunny day at the beach.
Island Style Galleries is home to tons of artisan gifts, home decor, and contemporary arts & crafts! Pick up a unique piece to bring some Sanibel style into your home, or grab a gift and share the Island vibe with family and friends!
Paradise Boutique is a cute little shop with all your kick-knack needs! T-shirts, gifts, home decor, and more are all found here, of course everything is unique and fits the beach aesthetic.
Peach Republic primarily showcases casual quality women’s wear, with a handful of children’s apparel available as well! A boutique style shop for clothes shopping and a few accessories available as well.
Naples Soap Company is a must visit while shopping around Sanibel Island! Carrying high-quality natural soaps, body care, bath bombs, and more! Check out their custom bath bomb tubes to mix and match scents and colors!
Sand Castle Gifts & Gourmet is filled to the brim with the most unique coastal gifts to share a piece of your Sanibel stay with anyone at home! Grab a one-of-a kind keepsake from shells to home decor.
Sanibel Olive Oil is here for the chefs! If you enjoy cooking a home made meal stop by and browse this unique collection of olive oils, balsamic vinegars, sauces, and more!
Sea Glass Lane is among the many women’s apparel boutiques but their specialty is color! Focused on channeling tropical hues of coastal life this women’s clothing store is perfect if you like to have a splash of color in your closet!
Trader Rick’s is for the artful woman, with a wide collection of patterned clothing pieces, colorful jewelry, and laid back fashion wear! Enjoying a day shopping on Sanibel this shop will have just what you need for a new look.
Toys Ahoy! This quaint book and toy store for children has a lovely unique collection for kids to choose from! Something to play with at the beach, a book to read while watching the sunset, or a stuffed animal to bring home, Toys Ahoy has it all.
Tiki Jim’s has that tropical tee you’ve been looking for! Their large collection of fun and festive t-shirts is exactly what you should be wearing that family beach photo. Grab something for friends at home from the gifts and novelty souvenirs.

Sanibel Square

2234-2250 Periwinkle Way, FL 33957

Sanibel square is a small little plaza but it is home to the must-visit Sanibel Bean, alongside “Ding” Darling’s Nature Store 2, Sanibel Beauty Salon, and Sanibel Fly Outfitters.

The Sanibel Bean is a local staple for your morning pick-me-up! Their delicious selections of handcraft coffee drinks, fruit smoothies, and fresh pastries is bound to start your day on the right foot, with a smile!
Ding Darling Nature Store 2 is one of Ding Darlings’ unique shops on Sanibel Island. All of the profits go towards the J.N. Ding Darling National Wildlife Refuge found right here on Sanibel!
Sanibel Beauty Salon is the perfect place to freshen up your look! Providing both men’s and women’s haircuts this beauty salon is highly recommended.
Sanibel Fly Outfitters has all of your fly fishing needs. Excellent men’s wear for fishing and spending time on the boat or beach, from shirts to hats the clothing is high quality and island style! With plenty of fishing gear stop in for all things fly fishing.

Bailey’s General Store Plaza

2477 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel FL 33957

This Plaza is the perfect place to stop in if you’re staying on Sanibel! With a variety of locally loved food spots, bike rentals, and Bailey’s iconic grocery & general store you must visit!

Bailey’s General Store has a rich history on the Islands and is fully staffed by the most amazing, personable, and helpful people on the island! This full-service grocery store has it all, groceries, wine & beer, quick meals to-go, home goods, and more!
Billy’s Bike Rental is the perfect place to rent a bike and enjoy Sanibel Islands’ many biking trails! Known for its bike paths and lovely rides, you’re missing out if you don’t explore the Island on two wheels!
George & Wendy’s Seafood Grill is home to locals and visitors alike! The live music is not to be missed and the menu is full of delicious fresh foods for lunch and dinner.
Joey’s Custard is among the ice cream shops found on Sanibel Island, however, this one isn’t just ice cream! You’ll find delicious frozen yogurt and a candy shop, the perfect solution for that something-sweet craving.
Island Cleaners is Sanibel’s cleaning service if you need to clean your home or rental property on the island!
The Grog Shop has a wide variety of beer, wine, liquor, and cigars! One of few liquor shops found on Island this one has it all ready to help check tropical cocktails off your grocery list.
Savoury Spoon is perfect for a post-beach bite right around lunchtime! Choose from a selection of sandwiches, paired with a tasteful drink from the juice bar! Offers smoothies with all the best tropical fruits and flavors as well.
Spoondrift Island Bowls is our favorite place for Poke in all of southwest Florida! Not just poke, but acai bowls as well, not to mention boba tea! Spoondrift bowls are fresh, delish, and made to order with custom topping chosen by you! Enjoy outdoor seating or grab and go.
Whims is a fun little boutique located amongst these service-based stores. Here is where the shop-a-holic can get some fun and eclectic jewelry, clothing, or gifts!

The Village Shops

2340 Palm Ridge Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957

The Village Shops has quite a few spots for apparel, unique gifts, home decor, and more! Browse around this selection of boutiques and specialty Sanibel Island shops.

Coca Y Cabana is an upscale boutique clothing store for both men’s and women’s clothing. This Sanibel Island shop is the perfect place to grab a new article of clothing for a nice dinner on the beach or a day on the water!
MacIntosh Books & Paper is a unique island find filled with games, books, stationary, and more! With something for all ages, this is the best spot to find a little something to keep the whole family entertained!
Priscilla’s of Sanibel is a quaint little trinket, clothing, and gift store! With some of the most fun and colorful accessories, the island has to offer there are so many gifts to choose from. Carrying games, stationary, baby toys, and a small selection of clothing items there is bound to be a hidden gem!
T2 Traders was opened by the owners of Traders with a hint of French inspiration. This Bistro & Wine Bar with a gift shop as well as a lovely outdoor patio is a great spot to have a nice meal, and a glass of wine, and soak in the island vibes!
Tribeca Hair Salon, Hair Color Experts this Sanibel Island salon specializes in hair coloring! Looking to get a touch-up on your trip? Or try something new, this is the Island salon for you! Both men’s and women’s hair cuts are available as well.
Why Knot is a women’s apparel store with an emphasis on quality and comfort! Dress to match Sanibel Island’s laid-back coastal vibes with quality pieces designed around looking good while feeling comfortable!
Watson Macrae Gallery is a lovely island art gallery with paintings, ceramics, sculptures, and glassware! The ideal gallery to find a nice piece of the island to bring home and enhance your living space!

Olde Sanibel Shoppes

630 Tarpon Bay Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957

If the number one thing on your Sanibel shopping list is a gift or two for friends and family this is the plaza for you! With 5 of these 7 shops specializing in gifts and accessories, you’re sure to find the perfect keepsake for everyone.

Amy’s Something Special is unique handcrafted clothing, jewelry, bedding, and crafts shop nestled among the Olde Sanibel Shops. It’s no doubt there is something special for everyone somewhere in Amy’s treasure box of a boutique!
Island Paws is Sanibel’s prime spot for your furry friend! If your pet decided to tag along on the family vacation, don’t forget to grab a souvenir for them as well. Here you’ll find toys, treats, and more!
JB Designs boasts a lovely collection of one-of-a-kind accessories! From jewelry, purses, and home decor there are so many unique island inspired pieces to simply browse or purchase!
Overeasy Cafe is one of Sanibel’s most iconic island breakfast spots! This is the best place to start your morning with a hearty breakfast full of island flavors!
On Island Sanibel has a huge selection of beach accessories and apparel! If you forgot a few things or simply want to take your beach day to the next level stop in at On Island and get everything you could need!
Sanibel Art & Frames is a full-service custom framing shop with prints and paintings available for purchase! With tons of tropical art with coastal designs and a wide variety of nature photography/landscapes, the Island’s beauty can be captured on your wall!
Suncatchers’ Dream is a full-service gift shop that even offers complimentary gift wrapping! We surely saved the best for last when it comes to this truly amazing Sanibel Island gift shop. Suncatchers’ Dream has the widest variety of gifts, so perfectly unique, there is something for everyone, so many treasures to choose from!

Captiva Island Shopping Centers

Chadwick’s Square, 5400 Plantation Rd, Captiva, FL 33924

2 Islands Gallery
Presenting work by professional Sanibel & Captiva artists, handcrafted jewelry & clothing

Captiva Provisions Company
Gourmet grocery store with extensive wine selection

Everything But Water
Designer swimwear, beach apparel & accessories

Footloose
Shoe store

H20 Outfitters
Beach apparel, sunglasses, accessories

Kay Casperson Lifestyle Spa & Boutique
Full-service spa & salon

Regatta
Designer resort wear for the entire family

J McLaughlin
Upscale women & men’s clothing

Starbucks Coffee
Chain coffee shop

Specialist Plazas & Stores

Islander Trading Post

1446 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-395-0888

Extensive and unique antique and collectibles store jammed with nostalgic fare from floor to ceiling.

She Sells Sea Shells

1157 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-6991

Visit She Sells Sea Shells Website Here

An award-winning Island Staple, this fun and eclectic store has a huge inventory of shells, jewelry, books, clothing and an extensive collection of handmade shell crafts and ornaments.

Town Center, 2496 Palm Ridge Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957

The Pecking Order Fried Chicken & Pies
Award-winning fried chicken to go

Subway Sandwich Shop
Standard subway menu

Pelican Place, 2440 Palm Ridge Rd, Sanibel, FL 3395

7

The Great White Grill
Sports bar with great memorabilia, pizza, signature sandwiches and extensive draft beer collection

Great White Grill restaurant on Sanibel Island

Palm Ridge Plaza, 2330 Palm Ridge Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957

Beach Floor & Decor Design Center
Kitchen & Bath, Floors, Window treatments

Island Pharmacies
Full-service pharmacy

Sanibel Deli & Coffee Factory
Soups, sandwiches, salads, vegan & gluten-free options

Rosie’s Cafe & Grill
Family Style Restaurant

The Islander Center, 2407 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

The Clam Shack
Fresh New England seafood

Cape Nails
Full-service nail salon

Forever Green Shops, 2025 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

Cip’s Place
A family-friendly restaurant with indoor and outdoor dining

Eileen Fisher
Upscale women’s apparel

Ace Hardware
Full-service hardware store

Forever Green shopping plaza on Sanibel Island

Sanibel Commons, 1039 - 1041 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957

Bait Box
Around since 1971, the Bait Box caters to all your fishing needs, live and frozen bait and charter services!

ICM Pool Service
Full-service pool service and repair and, condo maintenance.

Whitney’s Bait and Tackle

1554 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-579-0399

Visit Whitney's Bait & Tackle Website Here

Full-service specialist fishing store including equipment, fishing license, bait, rod and reel repair and offering extensive charter/tour services.

Whitneys Bait and Tackle Store Sanibel Island

Gene’s Books

2365 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-1446

Visit Gene's Books Website Here

Gene’s Books is an incredible store consisting of two buildings piled up with books of all genres. You can spend hours finding numerous treasures from all kinds of eras. A must-see for bookworms.

CJ'S Swimwear

2359 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-395-3733

Visit CJ'S Swimwear Website Here

Unique and affordable swimwear, all original designs.

Island Seafood Market Sanibel

2330 Palm Ridge Rd, #9, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-283-2525

Visit Island Seafoods Website

Fresh fish market.

Norris Furniture & Interiors

1025 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-579-0412

Visit The Norris Furniture Website Here

Finest quality, upscale home furnishings.

T-shirt Hut

1504 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-1415

Affordable and original T-Shirts and sweatshirts.

JRods Surf, Fish & Style

630 Tarpon Bay Road, Sanibel, FL 33957

Fishing equipment and fashion.

Huxters Market, Deli & Liquor

1203 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, FL 33957
239-472-2151

Visit Huxters Market's Website Here

Huxters Market, Deli and Liquors originated in the 1950s as a “huckster” selling fruits and vegetables out of his truck along Sanibel’s Periwinkle Way. Over the years, the business evolved and in 1973, the store was built and included the Market & Deli and our own Liquor Store.